This summer, while sitting on our porch, I heard crunching twigs behind me and noticed my daughter’s eyes widen as she loudly whispered, “Mom. There are two men walking across the lawn.”
I stood up, turned around, and saw that, indeed, there were two men walking with focus and intent toward us. So, I did what any Minnesotan would do, and asked, “Hi. Can I help you?”
“Do you mind me asking – how long have you lived here?” said the elder of the two.
An unexpected question, perhaps, but he seemed friendly enough.
“Well – we’ve been in this house for 30 years now,” I replied.
“Oh – wow,” he said. “Well, my name is Tim Dunn and…”
Before he could get out another word, Jacques and I both said, “Ah – you’re one of the Dunn boys.”
When we first moved into the neighborhood, we had heard stories of families current and past and all of the houses up and down the block were referred to by the most notable families who had lived in them. Even today, we still do that. There’s the old Eckley house, the old Cooney house, and the old Phillippe place evoking memories of times past. And we had bought the old Dunn house.
The man on the lawn smiled and nodded, saying, “Ah so you’ve heard of us, then.”
Indeed, we had. In fact, there had been two generations of Dunn boys in the house – both the father and uncles of the man on our lawn, and then he and his brothers took up residence sometime later. And now, here he was with his son visiting town to show him where he had spent his early years.
“This is probably going to sound crazy, but my father died this past year and since he passed, I’ve been thinking a lot about his ice skates. You didn’t by any chance find any skates when you moved in,” he asked. “I just remember an old wooden box in the attic where my father and his brothers kept their skates. And me and my brothers would stuff them with socks so we could skate over at the park.”
Well – 30 years is a long time. We had done a lot of living and made a lot of changes to the house in that period, but there was a vague memory of the dark reaches of the attic eaves that could, perhaps, have hidden treasures.
Jacques took this as an interesting challenge and we learned the Dunns were traveling on west of town, but would be back through Minneapolis by the weekend. So, we exchanged numbers and said we would text if we found anything.
Within a couple hours of their departure, Jacques had scrounged in the attic, found the old wooden box, bravely reached in to the dark expanse, and found the Dunn brothers’ skates – all three pair.
That, my friends, isn’t the best part of the story. It was what we learned when Tim and his wife returned to gather up the skates a few days later that makes this a good Halloween tale.
After sharing memories of his early childhood, of his grandfather who had originally owned the house before selling it to his father, Tim then told us of the grandmother he never knew, Catherine Dunn, or Kitty, as she was known.
To be fair, we had heard stories of this ill-fated Mrs. Dunn since we bought the house. In fact, at the closing in 1991, as we lay down our pens, the prior owner spoke up and said, “Well, now that you own the place, I should probably tell you about the ghost.”
She informed us that there was a woman who appeared while they were doing renovations on the place. One night, as her partner went to get a drink of water, he had seen a woman standing in front of the cabinetry waiting to be affixed in the kitchen. The glowing woman dressed all in white stood and faced him with a quizzical tip to her head.
He simply answered the implied question by telling her that the cabinets would upgrade the kitchen, and that they were hoping to have the place renovated for a family to buy within the next year. At that, the glowing woman nodded, smiled, and walked out through the wall of the house.
I’m sure our faces showed our surprise, as the prior owner said, “Oh. Don’t worry. We are sure she’s friendly. In fact, we think she’s the original Mrs. Dunn, who died while shoveling when she slipped and hit her head. She just stayed around to watch over the place.”
And now, here was the grandson of the original Mrs. Dunn telling us her story. Apparently, Catherine was an energetic spitfire that everyone called Kitty. She easily kept up with her active sons and husband, and when she died, her heartbroken husband married an older relative named Madonna who had a tough time managing the busy household.
After several years, Madonna convinced her husband to let the then young adult sons take over the house while they moved to a smaller, quieter home in St. Paul. That’s when Kitty, the ghost, was most active overseeing – and protecting – her sons.
Ultimately, it was Tim’s father who got married and remained in the house after his brothers moved on. And they stayed there, raising their three children until Tim turned 10 and they moved to Florida.
“Did you ever encounter Kitty’s ghost?” asked Tim, after he reiterated his family history. “Because my mom is convinced Kitty saved my sister’s life.”
Here’s the story. Tim’s younger sister always sat in her high chair in the corner of the kitchen, which, at the time, featured a drop ceiling covering up pipes from above. It was a spot that was out of the way of the active family swirling about the kitchen.
Then one day, as Tim’s mother was stirring a pot on the stove, she felt an urgent need to move her baby daughter in the chair to the other side of the kitchen. It was unexplainable – and also incontestable – it just had to be done. So, she picked up the chair with daughter inside and set her down on the other side of the kitchen.
Instantly, the ceiling caved in right over the spot where her daughter had been moments before. Tim’s sister was saved, and Tim’s mother – to this day – thanks the mother-in-law she never knew for that.
As we hand out candy this weekend, we will be thinking of the kind overseer of this house named Kitty. And wonder whether some day in the future this will become the Old Koppel House.